Export documents
The same shipment, typed five times: where export documents disagree
An invoice number typed two ways can hold up an IGST refund. A missed declaration on a shipping bill can cost an incentive. Here is where the documents for one shipment disagree, what it costs, and what can be repaired afterwards.

The short version
- The shipping bill is your IGST refund claim. Customs matches each invoice on it against GSTR-1, and a mismatch stops the refund for that invoice.
- SB005, an invoice number that differs between the two, is what customs calls the most common error. The usual cause is one invoice for GST and another for export.
- RoDTEP is claimed item by item on the shipping bill. If it is not claimed there, no credit accrues.
- Mistakes in GSTR-1 can be amended. Mistakes on the shipping bill are slow, costly or permanent.
- Under a letter of credit, documents need not be identical but must not conflict, and the invoice description must match the credit.
Sources last checked on . Rules like these change, so confirm the current position before you act.
India’s Foreign Trade Policy lists three mandatory documents (opens in a new tab) for an export: the transport document, a commercial invoice cum packing list, and the shipping bill. Three sounds manageable.
The trouble is that the same handful of facts, who sold what to whom, how much, at what value, under which code, gets typed again and again by different people. Your sales team types it into the proforma. Someone in dispatch types the invoice and packing list. Your customs broker (CHA) types the shipping bill from a PDF. Your accountant types the GST return at the end of the month. The shipping line types the bill of lading. If there is a letter of credit, the buyer’s bank typed its own version before any of you.
Each retyping is a chance for two documents to disagree. This article is about which disagreements cost money, and which can still be repaired after the vessel has sailed.
The shipping bill is your IGST refund claim
If you export on payment of IGST, you do not file a separate refund application. The shipping bill is the application. Customs’ system takes each invoice on it and matches it against what you declared in GSTR-1, then returns a response code for that invoice. CBIC’s guide to IGST refunds (opens in a new tab) sets out the codes, and Chennai Customs published the same table (opens in a new tab) again in 2025.
| Code | Meaning | Usual cause | Who fixes it |
|---|---|---|---|
| SB000 | Validated | None | Nobody |
| SB001 | Invalid shipping bill number | Typing error in GSTR-1 | You, by amending GSTR-1 |
| SB002 | Export manifest not filed | The shipping line has not filed, or its details do not match | The shipping line |
| SB003 | GSTIN mismatch | Shipping bill filed under a different GSTIN or a PAN | You, in GSTR-1; sometimes the customs officer |
| SB004 | Record already received | Duplicate transmission | Nobody; it is not an error |
| SB005 | Invalid invoice number | Invoice number differs between shipping bill and GSTR-1 | Depends where the mistake is |
| SB006 | Gateway manifest not available | Shipments from inland depots where the port manifest is missing | The shipping line |
Two things happen before any of this. First, the GST system forwards nothing to customs unless both GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B are filed and the IGST you paid in GSTR-3B is at least what you declared on exports. Second, the export table in GSTR-1 must carry the shipping bill number, its date and the port code. A 2018 CBIC circular (opens in a new tab) noted that records missing these never reach customs at all.
SB005, and the habit that causes it
The guide calls SB005 “the most common error”. It gives two causes. One is plain typing mistakes. The other is that the exporter “uses two sets of invoices, one invoice for GST and another invoice for exports”.
That second habit is widespread, and you can see how it starts. The buyer wants a commercial invoice in dollars with their purchase order number and your bank details. The accountant wants a tax invoice in the GST format with a number that fits the software. So two documents get made, with two numbers, and each ends up in a different government system. CBIC’s position in the same guide is that the invoice declared in the shipping bill should be the GST invoice.
GST rules make it worse in a small way. Rule 46 (opens in a new tab) limits an invoice number to 16 characters, unique within the financial year, with only hyphens and slashes allowed as special characters.
How one invoice becomes two numbersIllustrative figures
Your export series prints invoices as EXP/KRR/2026-27/00142. That is 21 characters. GST allows 16, so your accountant enters EXP/26-27/00142 in GSTR-1. Your CHA, working from the PDF, types the long version into the shipping bill.
Both are the same invoice. To the customs system they are two different ones, and the refund for that invoice stops with SB005.
How you fix it depends on which side is wrong. A mistake in GSTR-1 is corrected through the amendment table in a later return. A mistake in the shipping bill cannot be amended once the manifest is filed, so CBIC created an alternative: the customs officer matches the two by hand. You submit a request, a concordance table mapping each GST invoice to its shipping bill invoice, and a fee of ₹1,000 per shipping bill. A 2021 circular (opens in a new tab) made this route permanent.
It works, but it is a visit to the custom house for something a shared invoice number would have prevented.
The same rule sets what an export invoice must say. It needs an endorsement that the supply is meant for export, either on payment of integrated tax or under bond or letter of undertaking without it, along with the recipient’s name and address, the delivery address and the country of destination. We read the consolidated rules as published by CBIC in September 2021, so check the current wording with your accountant.
Values matter as well as numbers. Where the value on the GST invoice and the value on the shipping bill differ, a GST circular (opens in a new tab) says the lower of the two is used when working out a refund of input tax credit.
A missed declaration on the shipping bill
Some incentives are not applied for later. They are claimed on the shipping bill, and if the claim is not there, there is nothing to apply for.
RoDTEP is the clearest case. Each item on the shipping bill is declared as claiming the credit or not. The customs advisory (opens in a new tab) that introduced the declaration is direct about it: if the claim is not specifically made in the shipping bill, no RoDTEP accrues, and no changes are allowed once the manifest is filed. Rates are tied to the 8-digit tariff code, so the code on your invoice is doing more work than it appears to.
Can it be corrected afterwards? The honest answer is that we could not establish a reliable route. Section 149 of the Customs Act (opens in a new tab) allows a shipping bill to be amended after export only on documentary evidence that existed when the goods were exported. In 2025 customs built a post-manifest amendment module (opens in a new tab), noting that most requests it had seen were to switch a RoDTEP declaration from no to yes, and that at that stage it could be used only to comply with a court order. Separate 2025 regulations (opens in a new tab) allow some post-export conversions within a year, with a senior officer’s approval for changes to fields such as the HS code, invoice value or quantity. Plan as if a missed claim is lost.
Two cautions. Schemes like this are extended in short steps: RoDTEP is currently notified up to 31 December 2026 (opens in a new tab), so check that it applies on your shipment date. And incentives interact: the refund guide notes that claiming the higher rate of drawback on a shipping bill makes it ineligible for the IGST refund.
Under a letter of credit, the bank reads only the paper
A bank examining documents under an LC does not know or care whether the goods are right. It compares paper with paper. The rules it applies, UCP 600, are narrower than exporters often assume, and stricter in one place.
The general test is that data in a document “need not be identical to, but must not conflict with” data in the other documents or the credit. The ICC’s briefing on this article (opens in a new tab) gives an example: an invoice for 500 green hats and a certificate showing 499 is a discrepancy. A different abbreviation of the same address is not.
The commercial invoice is held to a tighter standard. Its description of the goods must correspond (opens in a new tab) with the description in the credit. If the LC says “100% cotton terry towels, 500 gsm” and your invoice says “cotton bath towels”, you have given the bank a reason to refuse, even though any buyer would know they are the same thing.
Then there is time. Documents must be presented not later than 21 calendar days (opens in a new tab) after the date of shipment, and within the validity of the credit. A discrepancy found on day 19 leaves two days to correct and re-present.
The ICC Academy’s list of common discrepancies (opens in a new tab) reads like a list of retyping errors: currency, unit price, total value and description on the invoice; ports of loading and discharge; the beneficiary’s name; quantities that differ from one document to the next; late presentation.
How often does this go wrong? The ICC’s own estimate, in a 2022 briefing on reducing discrepancies (opens in a new tab), is that between 65 and 80 percent of presentations are refused the first time. An older academic study by Ronald Mann (opens in a new tab), covering 500 transactions in the United States, found that the documents complied in fewer than a quarter of cases. Most were paid anyway, because buyers waived the discrepancies. A waiver, though, is the buyer’s choice. In a falling market, a discrepancy is a way out of the contract.
The mismatches with no error code
Not everything produces a code or a refusal notice. Some disagreements simply cause a phone call, a held container or a week’s delay.
- Cartons and weights. The packing list total, the shipping bill and the bill of lading draft should agree on the number of packages and the gross weight. The refund guide lists container numbers and package counts that differ between shipping bill and manifest among the errors behind SB002.
- Names. Consignee and notify party should be copied from the purchase order or LC, not typed from memory. “Pvt Ltd” against “Private Limited” is harmless in most places and a nuisance in a few.
- Terms. If the proforma says FOB and the invoice says CIF, the values will not reconcile, and someone will ask why.
- The bank. The shipping bill names your bank branch. If the payment later arrives at a different bank, the two have to be linked before the entry can be closed. Our article on payment realisation under the 2026 FEMA rules covers that side.
What can still be fixed after the vessel sails
| Problem | Can it be fixed? | How |
|---|---|---|
| Wrong shipping bill number or invoice details in GSTR-1 | Yes | Amend in a later GSTR-1 |
| Invoice number on the shipping bill differs from GSTR-1 | Yes, with effort | Request to customs with a concordance table and a ₹1,000 fee |
| Manifest not filed, or its container details wrong | Yes | The shipping line files or corrects it |
| RoDTEP not claimed on the shipping bill | Assume not | Limited routes after export; see above |
| LC discrepancy, time left to present | Yes | Correct and re-present |
| LC discrepancy, no time left | Only if the buyer agrees | Ask the buyer to waive it |
The pattern is consistent. Mistakes on your side of the GST return are repairable. Mistakes on the shipping bill are expensive, slow or permanent. That is where a check before filing earns its keep.
A ten-minute check before the shipping bill is filed
Your CHA sends a checklist, the draft shipping bill, for approval before filing. Most exporters approve it by reply-all. Read it against the invoice instead.
- One invoice, one number. The number on the checklist is the number your accountant will put in GSTR-1, character for character, and it fits in 16 characters.
- GSTIN, not a PAN, and the right one if you have several registrations.
- HS code at 8 digits, the same on the invoice and the checklist.
- RoDTEP claimed for each item that is eligible, and the drawback entry as you intend it.
- Value, currency and Incoterm as on the invoice.
- Quantity and unit for each line.
- Packages, net and gross weight as on the packing list.
- Consignee, notify party and ports as on the purchase order or LC.
- If there is an LC: the goods description copied word for word, the latest shipment date, and the last date for presentation worked out and written down.
Better still is to stop retyping. Our Order & Docs Desk produces the proforma, commercial invoice and packing list from one order record and compares them with the purchase order before anything is released; the statutory filing stays with your CHA. A single spreadsheet that everyone copies from, and nobody types over, gets you most of the way.
Questions exporters ask
What is the SB005 error in an IGST refund?
SB005 means the invoice number on the shipping bill does not match the invoice number declared in GSTR-1. If the mistake is in GSTR-1 it can be amended in a later return. If it is in the shipping bill, customs can match the invoices manually on a request with a concordance table and a fee of ₹1,000 per shipping bill.
Can a shipping bill be amended after the goods are exported?
Only in limited cases. Section 149 of the Customs Act allows amendment after export on the basis of documentary evidence that existed when the goods were exported, and customs procedures for this are narrow. Treat the shipping bill as final once it is filed.
Should the commercial invoice and the GST invoice be the same document?
CBIC’s guidance is that the invoice declared in the shipping bill should be the GST invoice. Using two invoices with two numbers is the usual cause of the SB005 error, so one invoice that carries both the GST particulars and the commercial details is the safer practice.
Is a separate packing list mandatory for export from India?
The Foreign Trade Policy lists a commercial invoice cum packing list as one of three mandatory export documents, and also accepts a separate invoice and packing list. A buyer or a letter of credit may still ask for a separate packing list.
Sources
- Foreign Trade Policy 2023, Chapter 2 (opens in a new tab)Directorate General of Foreign Trade. Paragraph 2.06 lists the mandatory documents
- Guide on IGST Refunds in ICES (opens in a new tab)CBIC Directorate General of Systems, copy hosted by Jawaharlal Nehru Custom House
- IGST refund response codes (opens in a new tab)Chennai Customs, 2025
- Circular 05/2018-Customs on invoice mismatch cases (opens in a new tab)CBIC, copy hosted by the Council for Leather Exports
- Circular 05/2021-Customs: officer interface made permanent (opens in a new tab)CBIC, as reported by TaxGuru
- Central Goods and Services Tax Rules, 2017 (consolidated) (opens in a new tab)CBIC. As at 24 September 2021; later amendments not checked
- Circular 125/44/2019-GST on refunds (opens in a new tab)CBIC
- RoDTEP declarations in the shipping bill (opens in a new tab)CBIC Systems advisory, copy hosted by LegalWiz
- RoDTEP notification extending the scheme to 31 December 2026 (opens in a new tab)Directorate General of Foreign Trade
- Customs Act 1962, Section 149 (opens in a new tab)Courtbook. A reproduction of the section
- Facility Circular 05/2025 (Exports) on the Post EGM Amendment Module (opens in a new tab)Chennai Customs
- Circular 11/2025-Customs on post-export conversion (opens in a new tab)CBIC, as reproduced by TaxGuru
- Technical Advisory Briefing No. 12: reading data in context (opens in a new tab)ICC Banking Commission, November 2024
- DOCDEX Decision 351 (opens in a new tab)International Chamber of Commerce. On the invoice description corresponding with the credit
- DCInsight queries and responses (opens in a new tab)International Chamber of Commerce. On the 21-day presentation period
- ISBP insights: avoiding common LC discrepancies (opens in a new tab)ICC Academy, April 2026
- Technical Advisory Briefing No. 3: reducing discrepancy rates (opens in a new tab)ICC Banking Commission, June 2022
- The Role of Letters of Credit in Payment Transactions (opens in a new tab)Ronald J. Mann, Michigan Law Review, 2000
This article explains how a rule or process works so you can ask better questions. It is not legal, tax, customs or banking advice. Export-Saathi is not a customs broker, bank or compliance adviser; confirm anything that affects a live shipment with your CHA, AD bank or adviser. Spotted an error? Tell us and we will correct it.



